Thursday, April 15, 2010

I'm eating humble pie -- yum!

I'm Eating Humble Pie -- yum! By Maree Anderson (for Writers Gone Wild)

Hi y'all,

I'm in the throes of editor revisions (not too many -- yay!) and upping the word-count (aaargh!) for From The Ashes, the manuscript Red Sage made me an offer on. So Judith, if you're reading this: 3,500 words down and 1,500 words to go. Sure hope you're gonna like the completely new scenes I added!

Hoping to have it finished by the weekend...because I still have those CIF and CAF forms to fill in. Gee. Writing multiple synopses in various lengths, my favorite thing in the entire world!

Anyway, the pending horror of multiple synopses aside, one of Kaylea's comments after her interview with Susan Lyons, made me chuckle.

Kaylea commented, "I need a road map--a good one--before I can sit down to start a draft. I can change things as I go, but I need that initial direction to have the main things figured out. I kind of envy you pantsers, but that doesn't mean I understand you."

And yanno, I've always considered myself to be one of those incomprehensible pantsers. At least, until a couple of weeks ago.

You see, I decided that I was going to have a go at this plotting business. Loads of writers do it. I've had an agent tell me over drinks that she wouldn't be keen on representing an author who couldn't outline--how would she be able to sell a manuscript or series on proposal only? And even my lovely editor has done *insert really scary number here* page story treatments before doing any actual writing.

So there I was, dedicated pantser, staring at a blank Word page, trying to get my head around character summaries and an outline.

Painful, much?

Oh. My. God. YES! Like pulling actual teeth with a pair of fricking pliers. I want to howl and whack my head on the desk just thinking about it, LOL.

I managed a paragraph of background and basic GMC for my two main characters. And then it took me two excruciating weeks to write a scene-by-scene outline for a 55-60,000 word manuscript. I hated every single minute of that process. It was a chore--a punishment, even!--to plant my butt in that chair and open up that document every day. Did I mention how much I hated it???

But I grit my teeth and stuck with it, because I figured that one day, I might benefit from learning how to do this.

And then I got to the fun part, the actual writing. And bugger me days (as we say in New Zealand), if the heroine didn't flip me the bird and decide she wanted to be an interior decorator instead of a lawyer.

Oh come on! Don't do this to me! I mean, let's stick to the blimmin' outline, please!

Okay. Not to panic. It's not the end of the world. Just go with it.

So I did.

And then, about five-thousand words into this story, my editor asked me if I had a novella just about ready, because they might want one. Like, asap. And I thought, shit-oh-dear, what do I tell her? "Are you kidding me?" isn't exactly professional.

So I told her I might have something in the works, and since it was already fully plotted (there's that evil word again!) I might just go for it and see if the story could be scaled back and work as a novella.

Ah, what the heck, we thought. Let's go for it, Maree. And if it isn't gonna work as a shorter book, it'll soon become painfully obvious to both of us.

Two weeks later, I had a 30,000 word novella. Better still, even though I had all my usual doubts--compounded to the nth degree by thinking this story probably sucked a big freaking kumara, considering how quickly I'd managed to write the dang thing--my editor loved the story. In fact, she gave me the best feedback I could ever ask for: "I absolutely loved it. Made a bad day go by fast! And to me, the ultimate recommendation for a story is that it gets the reader through a bad day."

So, there you go. Even if this story ultimately isn't suitable, this ultimate pantser is eating humble pie. Because I truly believe that I would not have been able to write this story so quickly, if I hadn't plotted it out first. Sure, some major things changed--especially the intended word length! But I'm convinced that this plotting business has some merit. Okay, okay, a shitfuckton of merit. Happy?

BTW, that humble pie I'm eating?

It's apple. My favorite ;-)

Maree

11 comments:

Wynter Daniels said...

I've worked both ways but having an outline or synopsis ahead is now the only way I can write.
And I am with you on those various length synopses - I despise having to do that.

Liane Gentry Skye said...

OMG, Maree, you've inspired me to try yet *again* to cough up a plot and stick to it. We won't discuss the long, winding road of dismal failures behind me LOL!

So scoot over, hand me a fork and cut me a heapin' helping of that humble pie! :)

Maree Anderson said...

Wynter: ah, synopses. Hell on earth, for sure! I used to write the damn book, summarise each chapter into a paragraph, and go from there. Happily, I'm now a bit more skilled. But they're still my least fave thing to do. I'd rather vacuum the house and clean the loo!

Liane: would you like ice-cream and sprinkles with that pie? LOL!

Kaylea Cross said...

I hate synopses too, but good for you Maree, for stepping into the light with me (go to the light, Maree...the light!).

I know lots of writers that honestly sit down and pound out a story without planning anything first, but it completely mystifies me. I guess I'm too much of an anal-retentive control freak to even contemplate such a thing. Hey, admitting it is step one of recovery, right?

SarannaDeWylde said...

Hey, whatever works. LOL. If I thought it work for me, I'd shovel it down like a banana split.

I hate being told what to do. Even if it's me doing the telling. :)

Maree Anderson said...

Saranna -- LOLOL! And guess what? This totally plotted novella is a tad plot-heavy.... I wonder how that could have happened? *headdesk* My editor is killing herself laughing, and I'm about to tackle revisions. I think I'll just do what I normally do and wing it ;-)

Jennifer L Hart said...

I tried working by outline for the first Laundry Hag, and halfway through the draft I realized I'd spoon-fed whodunit to the reader. So I switched killers 30K in.

I guess my outline was more of a what not to do ;-)

I m going to try though with my new WIP. Trying to world build a universe 50 years in the future without an outline is like dancing on the edge of madness.

And there is no pie there.

Liane Gentry Skye said...

OMG, Do I feel a chapter of Pantser's Anonymous in the making? Shall we write our own twelve step program and try to stick to it? ;)

Maree Anderson said...

Jennifer, no pie? Oh noes! I actually read in the last RWA mag that one of the authors hired someone to keep track of all her characters' details etc. She provided some fancy spreadsheet for the author. Whoa. Beats having your head explode trying to keep track of everything, I guess.

Hey, Liane, call it Barnstormers Anonymous and I'm in!

Virtual pie, anyone?

SarannaDeWylde said...

Hey, have you guys tried Liquid Binder? If you use it everyday, it's free.

You can do all sorts of spread sheets, character sheets, plot points, it's really cool and I'd love it if I wasn't a pantster.

Maree Anderson said...

OMG, I'd die! Truly. My DH got me One Note, which lets you do all sorts of cool stuff with mind-mapping and he thought it'd be fab for plotting a book. Epic fail on my behalf. Just got so bored, I ended up writing the dang book instead. Yes, I am totally hopeless.

 

Made by Lena